Carriers Payment Details Personal Carriers ASI Insurance (866) 274-8765 Report a Claim Pay Online Berkshire Insurance (877) 680-2442 Report a Claim Pay Online CHUBB Insurance (800) 777-2131 Report a Claim Pay Online Farmers of Salem (800) 498-0954 Report a Claim Pay Online Foremost Insurance (800) 528-5995 Report a Claim Pay Online Franklin Mutual (973) 948-3120 Report a Claim Pay Online Foremost (Bristol West) (800) 958-6120 Report a Claim Pay Online Guard Insurance (570) 825-9900 Report a Claim Pay Online Hyundai Insurance (855) 436-3467 Report a Claim Pay Online J&J Insurance (800) 487-7565 Report a Claim Pay Online Kingstone Insurance (800) 364-7045 Report a Claim Pay Online MassMutual Insurance 1-800-272-2216 Report a Claim Pay Online Markel/First Comp (800) 431-1270 Report a Claim Pay Online Mercury Insurance (800) 987-6000 Report a Claim Pay Online Metlife Insurance (877) 337-3200 Report a Claim Pay Online Nationwide Insurance (877) 669-6877 Report a Claim Pay Online National General (888) 325-1190 Report a Claim Pay Online Narragansett Bay (800) 343-3375 Report a Claim Pay Online Neptune Flood (888) 211-2776 Report a Claim Pay Online Plymouth Rock (888) 211-2776 Report a Claim Pay Online Progressive Insurance (877) 776-2436 Report a Claim Pay Online RT Specialty Insurance 888-867-1124 Report a Claim Pay Online Selective Insurance (866) 455-9969 Report a Claim Pay Online Stillwater Insurance (855) 712-4092 Report a Claim Pay Online Travelers Insurance (877) 878-2468 Report a Claim Pay Online Safeco Insurance (877) 566-6001 Report a Claim Pay Online Tapco Insurance (800) 334-5579 Report a Claim Pay Online TypTap Insurance (844) 289-7968 Report a Claim Pay Online Tuscano Insurance (724) 836-1510 Report a Claim Pay Online Universal Insurance (800) 425-9113 Report a Claim Pay Online Wright Flood Insurance (800) 820-3242 #7 Report a Claim Pay Online Homeowners Insurance (888) 210-5235 Report a Claim Pay Online Personal Umb Insurance (800) 564-1799 Report a Claim Pay Online Providence Insurance (877) 763-1800 Report a Claim Pay Online